Press "Enter" to skip to content

A Case for Irony (Tanner Lectures on Human Values) by Jonathan Lear

By Jonathan Lear

In 2001, Vanity Fair declared that the Age of Irony used to be over. Joan Didion has lamented that the USA within the period of Barack Obama has turn into an "irony-free zone." Jonathan Lear in his 2006 publication Radical Hope regarded into America’s middle to invite how could we dispose ourselves if we got here to consider our lifestyle was once coming to an finish. right here, he mobilizes a squad of philosophers and a psychoanalyst to once more forge a thorough approach ahead, through arguing that no surely human lifestyles is feasible with out irony.

Becoming human shouldn't be taken with no consideration, Lear writes. it truly is anything we accomplish, anything we get the grasp of, and prefer Kierkegaard and Plato, Lear claims that irony is among the crucial instruments we use to do that. For Lear and the individuals in his Socratic discussion, irony isn't approximately being cool and indifferent like a participant in a Woody Allen movie. That, as Johannes Climacus, considered one of Kierkegaard’s pseudonymous authors, places it, “is anything in simple terms assistant professors assume.” as a substitute, it's a renewed dedication to dwelling heavily, to experiencing each disruption that shakes us out of our ordinary methods of tuning out of existence, with all its vicissitudes. whereas many over the centuries have argued another way, Lear claims that our emotions and needs have a tendency towards order, a constitution that irony shakes us into seeing. Lear’s exchanges together with his interlocutors develop his claims, whereas his reviews as a practising psychoanalyst carry an emotionally gripping measurement to what's at stake—the psychic charges and merits of dwelling with irony.

Show description

Read Online or Download A Case for Irony (Tanner Lectures on Human Values) PDF

Similar psychoanalysis books

Freud on Coke

"Freud on Coke" via David Cohen (Retail Epub)

Print ISBN: 9780956544506
eISBN: 9781908122063
Publisher: Cutting facet Press/Andrews united kingdom
Dewey: 150. 19/52
Publication Date: 14 Feb, 2011
Pages: 349
Category: Psychology
LCCN: BF173. F85
Language: English
Edition: 1

The tale of Freud's involvement with cocaine and the way it affected learn lengthy after he died. .. The ebook tells of a few drug comparable tragedies Freud used to be occupied with together with the dying of Ernest Fleischl and that of the fewer popular Otto Gross who was once an outstanding analyst, a cocaine addict and has complicated principles approximately intercourse which led him to founding an orgiastic commune in Italy. Freud devotees can be unsatisfied with the e-book since it depicts their hero as all too human however it is a balanced view!


David Cohen justly describes Freud on Coke as “half background, part polemic”, that is a good self-declaration concerning the ebook, for Cohen doesn't try and cover what sounds like his dislike for the guy. although, Freud’s theories definitely carry a few weight with the writer for they're utilised in his research: “Any try and comprehend Freud has to confront the truth that he used to be, from time to time, a grasp of denial. the nice unanswered query is whether or not he used to be conscious of that element of himself” (Cohen 27). This illustrates how Cohen makes use of psychoanalytic approach to examine Freud himself – was once he in denial? – there's a seduction of his conception concerned; as a degree of the guy. The booklet itself is split into 3 sections. within the first half, Cohen bargains with Sigmund Freud’s personal use of cocaine, his writing at the subject and what it may exhibit approximately his paintings and character. within the moment half, he examines the advance of the introspective drug-use culture following Freud within the 20th century. And thirdly, he examines the country of play with medicinal drugs this day when it comes to their socio-medical-political place.

The Legacy of Sandor Ferenczi

A massive within the historical past of psychoanalysis, Sandor Ferenczi constructed rules in regards to the analytic state of affairs and the patient-analyst courting that count on key insights of latest psychoanalytic thought.  but, simply lately has Ferenczi began to obtain the popularity he merits. within the Legacy of Sandor Ferenczi, editors Lewis Aron and Adrienne Harris have introduced jointly prime Ferenczi students from around the globe to specify Ferenczi's position in psychoanalytic background and to reevaluate his contributions within the mild of present concept and perform.

Freud’s Technique Papers: A Contemporary Perspective

This landmark publication is a superb remark on Freud's psychoanalytic procedure and the way it's included in modern scientific perform. Freud's easy strategy papers are integrated, in order that the reader has Freud's personal phrases to check with the perspectives brought.

Psychoanalytic Studies of Creativity, Greed, and Fine Art: Making Contact with the Self

During the heritage of psychoanalysis, the examine of creativity and positive artwork has been a unique drawback. Psychoanalytic reports of Creativity, Greed and positive paintings: Making touch with the Self makes a special contribution to the psychoanalytic research of artwork by way of focusing realization at the courting among creativity and greed.

Additional resources for A Case for Irony (Tanner Lectures on Human Values)

Example text

The point of Socratic irony is not Â�simply to destroy pretenses, but to inject a certain form of not-knowing into polis life. This is his way of teaching virtue. And it shows the difficulty of becoming human: not just the arduousness of maintaining a practical identity in the face of temptation, but the difficulty of getting the hang of a certain kind of playful, disrupting exisÂ�tence that is as affirming as it is negating. It is constitutive of human excellence to understand—that is, to grasp practically—the limits of human understanding of such excellence.

599b–c) Plato’s answer: There is Socrates, for he is the one genuinely concerned with promoting health. Those who put themselves forward as doctors are in effect gratifiers and drug-dealers: helping those who are addicted to an unhealthy life extend their sick lives. (7) Among all shepherds, is there a shepherd? 26 (8) Among all the wise, is there a wise person? There is Socrates, for he alone knows that he does not know (Apology 23a–b). And so on. These questions all have the same form—and in each case the possibility for irony arises by showing that the pretense falls short of its own aspiraÂ� tion.

There is Socrates, for he alone knows that he does not know (Apology 23a–b). And so on. These questions all have the same form—and in each case the possibility for irony arises by showing that the pretense falls short of its own aspiraÂ� tion. That is, a social pretense already contains a pretense-laden understanding of its aspiration, but irony facilitates a process by which the aspiration seems to break free of these bounds. In each case a purported totality is interrogated as to whether any of its members actually fits the bill.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.94 of 5 – based on 39 votes